Last week, we detailed the advantages of press braking, comparing it to roll forming as a metal fabrication bending process. Although they have little in common, other than process category, both are important and have many uses. More than anything, choosing one over the other depends mainly on the end product undergoing fabrication. This week, we’ll take a look at closer look at roll forming specifically.
What is roll forming?
Roll forming is a shaping process, and it can be fascinating to watch, as it is completed as a single, continuous bending operation. Roll forming takes coiled sheet metal and passes it through a series of horizontal, rotating dies to produce a cross-section that is uniform in shape and size.
What are the advantages of roll forming?
The most impressive aspect of roll forming is just how well it handles the shaping and bending of even very long products. This is probably its biggest advantage over press braking, as press brakes can only bend items that are the length of the brake’s bed — at most, 12 feet in length. So while the majority of products can be most cost-effectively and efficiently bent via press brake, there are times when it makes more sense to roll form them instead.
Roll forming also produces an attractive finish without adding an additional finishing step, and secondary processes such as punching can be incorporated directly into the roll forming run instead of added on as a secondary process.
What are the disadvantages of roll forming?
In general, roll forming is most common and best for use in low-mix, high volume environments where these types of production runs — especially of very large items — are the norm. Roll forming is rarely, if ever, cost-effective for prototyping or short runs of products.
And although roll forming allows fabricators to add tooling to create just about any shape, even those that are extremely complex, tooling to create those shapes can be exorbitantly expensive. In fact, roll forming tooling can only be used for a single product, and not reused in other ways (similar to metal stamping with dedicated tooling), which can add to the overall production cost of some products.
Another disadvantage is that it can only form on two sides. This is where secondary processes often become necessary with roll-formed pieces as any forming on the ends must be completed after the rolled part has been cut from the roll.
Finally, roll forming sometimes results in end flare due to linear stresses if part geometry is not carefully considered, an issue that is not a concern with other types of forming operations, like press braking.
Roll forming: A specialty metal fabrication process with narrow, but important applications
Although roll forming is not the workhorse that press braking is in metal fabrication environments, it is still a necessary operation with many important uses, especially when items are very long, or a fabricator specializes in a product mix with low variety and high volume.
EVS Metal is an ISO 9001:2015-certified leader in quality precision sheet metal fabrication with four locations across the U.S. Our stainless steel and aluminum manufacturing capabilities expand far beyond traditional fabrication practices in order to provide clients with a distinct competitive advantage — the option to utilize EVS’ comprehensive range of in-house manufacturing solutions, including multiple forming solutions.
Whether our clients require product design and engineering, machining, powder coat finishing, or assembly and integration, our team of experts delivers quality outcomes that meet our customers’ requirements and exceed their expectations. We guarantee that each job will result in the production of superior products at highly competitive prices for every order, no matter the size. For more information or to request a quote, contact EVS Metal today.